The Gig Chronicles: Twist, Shout, and a Broken Bass

Sixth grade. Backstage. Dressed in a black turtleneck, trying not to forget my line.

Nathan stood a few feet to my side, black Stratocaster in hand.

And I was focused on that walk-up bass line that starts the song. That…

Dun. Dun. Dun. Dun…

We were going to play “Twist and Shout” by The Beatles.

I kept running it over and over again, trying to get that walk-up bass line under my fingers and wondering how many times I was going to mess it up once we actually got onstage. Eventually, we walked out.

The stage was built into the school cafeteria, and I remember the bright stage lights coming at me and looking out at a room full of people.

I was nervous. Very nervous. I almost wasn’t ready.

But then came the count-off.

Dun. Dun. Dun. Dun.

We started playing.

Almost all of my attention went toward one thing:

Do my part right.

I was trying to hear the other guys. I was trying to stay with them. I was trying to remember where I was in the song. But mostly, I was concentrating as hard as I could on making my fingers play that little line when they were supposed to.

But to explain how I ended up there, why I was playing bass in the first place, and why I may not have even been playing a bass by the time we got onstage, we need to back up a little.

Technically, this wasn’t my first time performing in front of people.

I’d played piano at a recital when I was little, although I’m not sure I completely understood what a recital was at the time. I remember sitting down at the piano, playing my piece like my teacher told me to, and then being startled when a room full of people suddenly started applauding behind me.

I’d performed in choir, too. And technically, I’d even been in a talent show before.

The year before, some of the same friends and I had decided we wanted to perform “Gel” by Collective Soul in the talent show. There was just one minor problem:

We couldn’t actually play it.

I don’t think we even owned all the instruments yet. So we borrowed some, got onstage, and pantomimed the whole thing.

We were apparently committed to becoming a band long before we were particularly concerned with the requirement that a band actually know how to play music.

But sixth grade was different. This would be my first band performance — the first time I’d take the stage and play live with a group.

This time, we were actually going to play.

I had gotten my first guitar, a sunburst Fender Stratocaster, not terribly long before. I had wanted to play guitar or bass for years, going all the way back to elementary-school fantasies about starting bands with friends.

Now I finally had a guitar.

What I didn’t have was much ability to play it.

I could barely make chord shapes. Changing between them in time was another matter entirely. My best friend Nathan was already a considerably better guitar player than I was and would show me parts, chords and things to try.

I struggled with essentially all of it.

I was very clearly the weakest musician in the group.

But I was so happy to be there.

I was excited just to be a part of it. I had wanted to do this for years, and now I finally had a guitar, I was playing with my friends, and we were actually going to get onstage and play a song.

I was super excited.

I also sure did suck.

Nevertheless, we were going to play the talent show.

There were four of us, although after all these years I can’t confidently remember exactly who filled every position. What I do remember is Nathan playing guitar, Trey playing drums, and Trey’s dad, Joe, helping us considerably while we tried to get everything together.

And then there was me.

Somewhere along the way, it became apparent that having me play the guitar part was probably not our strongest strategic decision.

Nathan’s dad had a bass.

So I became the bass player.

Not because I was secretly a natural bassist.

Because the bass part seemed like something I might actually be able to survive.

The song was “Twist and Shout” by The Beatles.

I can still hear that ascending bass line in my head.

Dun. Dun. Dun. Dun.

Today, it’s not exactly the sort of bass line that would keep me awake at night.

In sixth grade?

It was hard.

I remember working on that walk-up over and over and struggling to make it happen cleanly and in time.

But we practiced, and somehow we were getting close enough that this might actually work.

And Then We Kept Making It Worse

Then, shortly before the talent show — I believe during a rehearsal a day or two beforehand — we discovered a problem.

The bass was out of tune.

We knew just enough to recognize that something didn’t sound right.

What we didn’t have was a tuner.

We also didn’t have anyone who knew how to tune a bass by ear.

So we started thinking.

Who at school knows music?

Of course.

The choir teacher.

We were already choir students, so taking the bass down to our sixth-grade choir teacher seemed like an entirely reasonable solution.

We explained that the bass was out of tune.

She explained that she didn’t really know how to tune a bass.

But collectively, we knew one important piece of information:

One of the strings was supposed to be an A.

Great.

There was a piano.

Play an A, match the string to it, problem solved.

Except there is more than one A on a piano.

I remember her asking which A it was.

I had no idea.

“It’s a bass.”

That was approximately the full extent of the technical information I was capable of providing.

So she picked an A and started turning the tuning key.

Unfortunately, she had picked the wrong octave.

Way, way too high.

She kept turning.

And turning.

And turning.

The pitch wasn’t getting where she expected it to go, so she kept tightening the string.

Eventually, something had to give.

It wasn’t the string.

The gear inside the tuning key — the little mechanism that actually tightens and loosens the tension on the string — broke.

At that point, we had officially moved from a problem to a disaster.

Instead of owning an out-of-tune bass, we now owned a broken bass.

From Bad to Worse

There were discussions about re-tuning the remaining strings and having me play the part somewhere else on the neck.

As I remember it, the tuning key that broke was on the A string — the third string on a standard four-string bass. And yes, that means it was one of the two strings in the middle.

That made things even more complicated. The bass line I’d practiced moved across several strings, so now I’d have to figure out a completely different way to play it while skipping over the unusable string.

There was just one problem with that plan:

I could barely play the bass line the way I’d practiced it.

Asking me to suddenly relearn where all those notes were somewhere else on the neck, immediately before the show, was not exactly setting me up for success.

Then came another idea.

What if we took my guitar and tuned it down to sound like a bass?

For anybody wondering, no, you cannot simply tune a normal guitar down an octave and call it a bass. At some point, the strings cease being strings and go completely slack and start flapping around like loose pieces of wire.

We discovered some version of that principle experimentally.

Looking back today, the obvious solution seems ridiculous in its simplicity:

Get another bass.

That’s it.

Borrow one.

Today, if somebody called me and said, “My bass broke and I have a show tonight,” I could probably make a few phone calls and have another instrument in their hands almost immediately. Guitar, bass, amp, drums, cables — after decades of playing music, I know enough musicians that finding replacement gear usually isn’t a particularly difficult problem.

But this wasn’t today.

This was a group of sixth graders whose professional network consisted largely of our parents and the choir teacher.

So instead, everybody scrambled.

And Then We Played

I don’t remember with absolute certainty how the final decision was made. My best recollection is that I ended up using my sunburst Stratocaster and playing some approximation of the bass line on the guitar in standard tuning.

What I do remember is standing there on stage right, looking down at that guitar and concentrating on my part like my life depended on it.

Stage right, incidentally, is still where I prefer to stand when I’m playing today.

I don’t know how accurate my bass line was.

I don’t know how many notes I missed.

I don’t know if anyone in the audience had any idea how close we had come to losing our bass entirely before the show.

What I do remember is that we played.

And people loved it.

They cheered. They applauded. We got the attention that comes with being the kids who had actually gotten up there and played in a band.

And I loved that.

Even then, before I had much justification for calling myself a guitar player, I loved being known as one. There was something about standing onstage with an instrument that felt right.

Was it a flawless performance?

There is absolutely no chance.

Was I playing the correct bass part?

Debatable.

Was I even playing a bass?

Apparently not.

But the show went on.

And somehow, despite the broken bass, the questionable emergency engineering and the fact that I could barely play my part in the first place, it felt like a success.

Looking back, that may have been a strangely appropriate introduction to performing music.

Sometimes something breaks.

Sometimes somebody is out of tune.

Sometimes the solution everyone comes up with is completely ridiculous.

Sometimes you’re standing there thinking, I am absolutely not prepared for this.

And then somebody counts the song off.

So you play.